The central requirements for diagnosis of ms are dissemination in space dis and dissemination in time dit of lesions in the cns, with the. Recommended diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis. The present study aimed to demonstrate that time to ms diagnosis could be shorter than 2010 revised criteria, and established after a single. These new criteria intended to replace the poser criteria and the. May, 2019 the latest revision of the mcdonald criteria for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis ms, released in 2017, was designed to facilitate early diagnosis of ms. Figure 1 shows kaplanmeier curves for the time to diagnosis of ms using the poser and mcdonald criteria for patients with cis who developed cdms. Earlier and more frequent diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. The 2010 revisions magnetic resonance imaging criteria for dis. The use of imaging for demonstration of dissemination of central nervous system lesions in space and time has been simplified, and in. Diagnosing multiple sclerosis using the mcdonald criteria. Criteria improving multiple sclerosis diagnosis at the. New evidence and consensus has led to further revision of the mcdonald criteria for diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. The international panel on ms diagnosis presents revised diagnostic criteria for. The mcdonald criteria were developed by an international panel in association with the national ms society of america, modified in 2005, and revised again in 2010 and 2017.
The 2010 mcdonald criteria make an important contribution to the diagnostic algorithm of ms, but some questions still remain about the validation of the new dis and dit definitions in a wider population of patients seen in daily practice, their sensitivity, specificity and prognostic value in other subpopulations, the status of ris and its. Ms diagnostic criteria according to mcdonald et al. In past versions of the mcdonald criteria, dis demonstrated by mri was based on the barkhoftintore criteria. The mcdonald criteria, used for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis ms, has been revised by a 30member international panel of ms experts cochaired by jeffrey cohen, md cleveland clinic and alan thompson, md university college london. Recommended diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis citeseerx. The mcdonald criteria are used to seek to establish evidence of damage to the central nervous system cns comprising of the brain and spinal cord. Diagnostic criteria have evolved over time from the schumacher criteria 1965, to poser criteria 1983, and finally to the mcdonald criteria 2001. The mcdonald criteria were devised in 2001 by a team led by professor ian mcdonald, and were most recently revised in 2010.
The diagnostic criteria for primary progressive ms remain unchanged in the 2017 mcdonald criteria from those in the 2010 mcdonald criteria, 4 but now allow symptomatic and asymptomatic mri lesions, as well as cortical and juxtacortical lesions. Recommended modifications to the mcdonald criteria. New research evidence and evolving knowledge since the previous 2010 mcdonald criteria for diagnosing ms compelled a 30member international panel of ms experts to consider whether revisions would improve the speed and accuracy of the diagnosis of ms while reducing the possibility of misdiagnosis. To investigate the impact of the 2017 revisions of mcdonald criteria on the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis ms in a cohort of patients with clinically isolated syndrome cis and dissemination in space dis of demyelinating lesions. They rely in mri detection or clinical demonstration of demyelinating lesions in the cns, which are. The new criteria are easier to apply and could lead to more and earlier diagnoses. Ian mcdonald who directed an international panel in association with the national multiple sclerosis society nmss of america and recommended revised diagnostic criteria for ms in april 2001. Polman ch1, reingold sc, banwell b, clanet m, cohen ja, filippi m, fujihara k, havrdova e, hutchinson m, kappos l, lublin fd, montalban x, oconnor p, sandbergwollheim m, thompson aj, waubant e, weinshenker b, wolinsky js. Since the first development of diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis ms, there have been regular revisions of disease definitions and diagnostic thresholds aimed at improving specificity while maintaining sensitivity. Tipsheet 2010 revised mcdonald diagnostic criteria for ms1 diagnosis of ms requires elimination of more likely diagnoses and demonstration of dissemination of lesions.
The mcdonald criteria were revised in 2005 polman et al. Considerations related to revisions to the mcdonald criteria. Importance in 2017, the international panel on diagnosis of multiple sclerosis revised the mcdonald 2010 criteria for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis ms. The 2017 mcdonald criteria continue to apply primarily to patients experiencing a typical clinically isolated syndrome cis, define what is needed to fulfill dissemination in time and space, and stress the need for no better explanation for the. Current standard for diagnosing ms is based in the 2018 revision of mcdonald criteria. The central requirements for diagnosis of ms are dissemination in space dis and dissemination in time dit of lesions in the cns, with the proviso that there should be.
Patients with a clinically isolated syndrome suggestive of multiple sclerosis ms background and objective. Additional clinicalattack simultaneous presence of both enhancing and nonenhancing ms typical mri lesions, or new t2 or enhancing mri lesion compared to baseline scan without regard to timing of baseline scan csf oligoclonalbands 1 attack and clinical evidence of 1 lesion. They have been extensively revised several times, most recently in 2017. However, even with the 2010 revised criteria, nearly 50 % of patients remain classified as possible ms following the first mri. Dr cohen said misdiagnosis with ms is quite common and the new criteria will. The new recommended revisions are expected to speed the diagnostic process and reduce the chance of misdiagnosis. Implementing the 2017 mcdonald criteria for the diagnosis. Implementing the 2017 mcdonald criteria for the diagnosis of. Revised diagnostic criteria of multiple sclerosis sciencedirect. Msuk revised mcdonald criteria expected to speed up.
Application of the mcdonald criteria for multiple sclerosis. In 2010, the international panel on diagnosis of ms met in dublin, ireland for a. Ian mcdonald, frcp,1 alistair compston, frcp,2 gilles edan, md,3. The mcdonald criteria, which were developed in 2001 by an international expert panel and revised several times, most recently in 2017, provide recommendations on the diagnosis of ms, including diagnosis after a single attack.
The use of imaging for demonstration of dissemination of. The 2010 revised mcdonald diagnostic criteria for ms are customarily used to determine a definitive diagnosis of ms. It is important to validate these criteria globally for their accuracy in clinical practice. Additional clinicalattack simultaneous presence of both enhancing and nonenhancing ms typical mri lesions, or new t2 or enhancing mri lesion compared to baseline scan without regard to timing of baseline scan. Apr 30, 2020 the mcdonald criteria, which were developed in 2001 by an international expert panel and revised several times, most recently in 2017, provide recommendations on the diagnosis of ms, including diagnosis after a single attack. The current version in use is the 2010 mcdonald criteria. The diagnostic criteria for primary progressive ms in the 2017 mcdonald criteria remain the same as those outlined in the 2010 mcdonald criteria, aside from removal of the distinction between symptomatic and asymptomatic mri lesions and that cortical lesions can be used. The mcdonald criteria have resulted in earlier diagnosis of ms with a high degree of both specificity and sensitivity, allowing for better counseling of patients and.
The mcdonald criteria is available to download below. Mcdonald criteria for ms may incorporate csf testing. December 21, 2017 national multiple sclerosis society. These 2010 revisions to the mcdonald criteria are likely to be applicable in pediatric, asian, and latin. Revisions underway to mcdonald criteria on ms diagnosis. These came as a consensus, based on evidencebased and expert opinions 2, aiming to improve on the previous mcdonald diagnostic criteria. Scientific advances in the past 7 years suggest that they might no longer. A 2010 revision to the mcdonald criteria which followed a 2005 update reflected better understanding of ms and improved mri techniques and made possible a. The 2010 revisions to the mcdonald criteria simplified the requirements for dissemination in time and space on mri and removed neurophysiological and cerebrospinal fluid csf testing from the diagnostic criteria for relapsingremitting ms. Aspects of the newest revisions were presented by jeffrey cohen, md, director of the experimental therapeutics program at.
Mcdonald diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis. Key points the 2017 criteria continue to permit dissemination in space dis with as few as two lesions in two locations periventricular, juxtacortical, infratentorial, spinal cord. This website was created with financial support from merck serono sa geneva, switzerland. Jan 10, 2018 an international group of experts has revised the 2010 mcdonald ms criteria. New orleans an upcoming revised version of the mcdonald diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis ms will likely expand the role of cerebrospinal fluid csf testing in diagnosing the. Summary of 2017 mcdonald criteria for the diagnosis of ms. The first set of criteria were published in 2001 by a team led by prof ian mcdonald.
The neurologist will make a diagnosis of ms based on established criteria, such as the revised 2010 mcdonald criteria 2. Magnims consensus on mri diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. Scientific advances in the past 7 years suggest that they might no longer provide the most uptodate guidance for clinicians and researchers. The magnetic resonance imaging in multiple sclerosis magnims, which is a european collaborative research network, published in 2016 new recommendations to upgrade the imaging diagnosis criteria for multiple sclerosis ms.
They are best applied to patients 11 years or older, according to first author alan j. The use of imaging for demonstration of dissemination of central nervous system. Application of the 2017 revised mcdonald criteria for. The mcdonald criteria are diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis ms. Application of the 2017 revisions of mcdonald criteria in our cohort led to. Jan 09, 2018 the mcdonald criteria should be applied primarily to patients with a typical clinically isolated syndrome that is, in whom the probability of ms is high.
The latest revision of the mcdonald criteria for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis ms, released in 2017, was designed to facilitate early diagnosis of ms. Realworld validation of the 2017 mcdonald criteria for. Tipsheet 2010 revised wlogos national multiple sclerosis. Magnims consensus on mri diagnosis of multiple sclerosis dr henry knipe and dr marcos gil alberto da veiga et al. The mcdonald criteria was developed adopted in 2001 to assist neurologists with diagnosing ms and includes guidelines for mri evidence, clinical exams and the use of spinal fluid.
The mcdonald criteria, written in 2001 and revised in 2010, is a means of diagnosing multiple sclerosis with sensitivity and speed, largely using mri scans. New ms diagnostic criteria in practice practical neurology. The revisions are made by a panel of ms experts who look at the most uptodate research on how ms appears and progresses in patients. International panel on diagnosis of multiple sclerosis target population. In past versions of the mcdonald criteria, dis demonstrated by mri was based on the barkhoftintore. Mcdonald criteria were originally introduced in 2001 1, revised in 2005 2, 2010 3, 2016 by magnims 4 and most recently in 2017 5. According to updates made in 2017, ms can be diagnosed based on these findings. The mcdonald criteria were developed in 2001 and updated in 2005 and 2010. The 2010 mcdonald criteria for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis are widely used in research and clinical practice. Thompson, md, and his colleagues on the international panel on diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. The introduction of the mcdonald criteria has enabled earlier diagnosis of multiple sclerosis ms. Tipsheet 2010 revised mcdonald diagnostic criteria for ms1 diagnosis of ms requires elimination of more likely diagnoses and. The criteria are named after ian mcdonald 19332006, a new zealand neurologist, who devised the original criteria with his international colleagues in 2001 1.
1038 798 1451 1026 1486 699 975 193 172 713 943 1140 1256 327 1482 322 1599 901 1471 1464 416 1450 1236 89 699 703 164 1185 1245